Supreme Court of Mississippi - Criminal Law Opinion
| Winters v. State | | Citation: 2024-KA-01105-SCT Opinion Date: June 4, 2026 Judge: David Sullivan Areas of Law: Criminal Law | A man was shot and paralyzed during an attempted armed robbery at his apartment late at night. The victim had agreed to sell marijuana to an acquaintance, who arrived with two others. Testimony at trial established that one of the men, masked and armed, demanded valuables before shooting the victim. Two codefendants, both indicted for their roles, described a plan to rob the victim, identified the masked shooter, and explained their own involvement. Investigation linked the accused to the scene through witness testimony, phone records, and a license-plate reader showing his vehicle at the location around the time of the crime. The accused's phone was also recovered at the scene.
The case was tried in the Oktibbeha County Circuit Court. At trial, the accused did not testify or present a defense. The jury found him guilty of aggravated assault and attempted armed robbery. He filed post-trial motions arguing the evidence was legally insufficient and the verdict contrary to the weight of the evidence, citing unreliable eyewitness identification, inconsistent accomplice testimony, and lack of physical evidence. The trial court denied these motions.
Reviewing the appeal, the Supreme Court of Mississippi considered whether the evidence was sufficient and whether the verdict was against the weight of the evidence. The Court held that the suggestive-identification claim was barred because it was not raised at trial. It found that the accomplice testimony, though somewhat inconsistent, was not so improbable or self-contradictory as to require reversal, especially given corroborating evidence. The Court concluded that physical evidence and testimonial evidence together were sufficient for a rational jury to convict. The Supreme Court of Mississippi affirmed the convictions for aggravated assault and attempted armed robbery. |
|
| Zattoni v. State of Mississippi | | Citation: 2024-KA-01382-SCT Opinion Date: May 28, 2026 Judge: David Sullivan Areas of Law: Criminal Law | After an argument at their shared residence, Joseph Zattoni’s girlfriend, Natalie Lambert, attempted to leave in her vehicle. Zattoni fired a gunshot as she drove away, causing her tire to go flat. He pursued Lambert, blocked her car, smashed her window, and forcibly placed her in his truck. The two drove around for several hours, during which Lambert tried to escape by jumping from the moving vehicle but was returned to the truck by Zattoni. Law enforcement, alerted to a possible abduction, eventually located Lambert, who displayed visible injuries. Zattoni was later arrested and charged with aggravated domestic violence, kidnapping, and felon in possession of a firearm, the latter charge enhanced due to his prior felony convictions.
The case was tried in the Hinds County Circuit Court. At trial, the jury heard evidence of Zattoni’s prior convictions and listened to an unredacted audio recording of his police interview, which included references to unrelated criminal activity and details of his criminal record. The jury found Zattoni guilty of kidnapping and felon in possession of a firearm, and he was sentenced as a nonviolent habitual offender. Zattoni appealed, arguing that the trial court erred by allowing prejudicial evidence regarding his prior convictions and by admitting the unredacted audio interview, both of which he claimed unduly influenced the jury.
The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed the case. It found that the trial court erred by not accepting the stipulation regarding Zattoni’s felony status before trial and by admitting the full, unredacted police interview, as these actions allowed unduly prejudicial material before the jury in violation of evidentiary rules. However, the court held that these errors were harmless in light of the overwhelming evidence supporting Zattoni’s guilt and the limiting instruction given to the jury. The Supreme Court of Mississippi affirmed Zattoni’s conviction. |
|
Explore the membership connecting anyone interested in the law, including lawyers, legal professionals, students, and legal enthusiasts, with benefits and resources to achieve their professional and growth goals. Free Justia Connect Practice Memberships unlock access to core program features, while upgraded Justia Connect Pro Memberships offer expanded benefits for lawyers. For anyone passionate about the law, the Justia Connect Public Membership provides valuable resources, exclusive discounts, and educational opportunities. www.justia.com
-----
Contact Us
News for Southwest Mississippi and East Central Louisiana, including Adams, Jefferson, Franklin and Wilkinson counties and Concordia and Catahoula parishes.Offices:
15044 Blue Marlin Terrace, Bonita Springs, FL 34135
601-431-2990
missloumagazine@gmail.com
Peter Rinaldi, publisher
Clarisse Washington, editor emerita