James L. Cummins
Second Amendment and Its English Roots by James L. Cummins
The Second Amendment is among the most debated provisions in the United States Constitution, yet its origins are remarkably clear to anyone who traces the history that produced it.
The 27 words ratified in 1791 did not emerge from abstract political theory. They grew directly from more than a century of English and colonial experience with governments that had used the control of arms as a tool of oppression. That history began in earnest with the English Game Acts of the seventeenth century, which restricted not only hunting but the possession of firearms among those deemed too poor or politically unreliable to be trusted with them.
The connection between arms and hunting in English law was explicit and deliberate. To disarm the common subject was to render him dependent, and the Game Acts accomplished exactly that under the cover of wildlife management. When King James II selectively enforced these laws against Protestant landowners while arming his Catholic supporters in the 1680s, he confirmed what many had long suspected: the regulation of arms was as much about political control as about any other stated purpose.
The English Bill of Rights, adopted in 1689 following the Glorious Revolution, responded directly to those abuses. Its guarantee that Protestants could keep arms suitable to their condition was understood not as a sporting provision but as a civil right, a check against the kind of targeted disarmament that James had practiced. William Blackstone, writing decades later in his Commentaries on the Laws of England, codified this understanding and gave it the legal language that American founders would carry into their own debates. In the colonies, those debates were urgent and concrete.
The memory of British attempts to seize colonial arms at Lexington and Concord in April 1775 was barely a decade old when the Constitutional Convention met in Philadelphia. Anti-Federalists who feared the power of the new central government insisted on explicit protections, and the right to keep and bear arms was among the least controversial of the provisions that became the Bill of Rights.
The militia clause that opens the amendment reflected the republican conviction that an armed citizenry was the proper alternative to a standing army that could be turned against the people. What the founders wrote into law in 1791 was the culmination of a long argument about the relationship between arms and liberty. They had watched England work out that argument through revolution, through legislation, and through the writings of its finest legal minds.
The Second Amendment was their answer, built on English foundations but shaped entirely by the American experience.
JOHN L. SULLIVAN, YOUR ALFA AGENT: Whether you’re a new driver or have years of experience, you need auto insurance coverage from a company you can trust to protect your family and vehicle. Alfa is ready to help you navigate through the coverage and protection you need, so you can sit back and enjoy the ride. Alfa offers many car insurance coverage options including liability, collision, comprehensive, roadside assistance, medical payments and loss of use among others. Our competitive policies and pricing will help protect you from financial risk and get back on the road. 422 Highway 61 North, Natchez, Suite 3, 601-445-8868. https://www.alfainsurance.com/agents/john-l-sullivan JSullivan2@alfains.com
-----
Contact Us
News for Southwest Mississippi and East Central Louisiana, including Adams, Jefferson, Franklin and Wilkinson counties and Concordia and Catahoula parishes.
Offices:
15044 Blue Marlin Terrace, Bonita Springs, FL 34135
601-431-2990
missloumagazine@gmail.com
Peter Rinaldi, publisher
Clarisse Washington, editor emerita